Media Relations Best Practice: Interview Summary Notes

A recent article in the Chicago Tribune profiled people who use part of their summer vacations for volunteer humanitarian service (link below). Among those interviewed was Paula Amenta, who had worked as a counselor at a camp for at-risk kids.

What country had Paula stated that she visited? Zambia.

What did the paper report? Zaire.

oh no u dint

 Ouch!

OK, it’s easy enough to bring this to the reporter’s attention and ask for a correction to be published in the next edition. However, papers usually publish corrections in some obscure corner of an inside page.

As a best practice, I write my own summary notes memo, either before or following an interview, and submit it to the reporter. If someone else is the designated interviewee, I am always present during the interview – whether it’s in person or by phone.

Before the interview, I ask the reporter for a preliminary list of questions or, at least, a topic outline. This enables me to gather internal information and prepare talking points for myself or the designated interviewee. I prepare talking points regardless of the level of the level of expertise. Those talking points then become the post-interview summary notes — attached, of course, to your friendly “thank you” note to the reporter.

reporter notebookIt’s a supplement to the reporter’s own note-taking and helps prevent misspelled names, misstated job titles, fact-flipping, and other inaccuracies.

Is it spoon-feeding? Do reporters balk? Sure, initially. I’ve found, however, that this practice can foster better relationships with reporters, even entice them to become beat reporters on your organization. Providing your summary notes can make reporters perceive you as helpful, responsive, and especially resourceful on sensitive issues or technically complex topics.

My memo also goes to the organization’s board members as well as cross-departmental/divisional managers and executives, who may decide to share it with their staff members. This way, I am the first and best news source. No need for them to turn on the news or open the paper and go, “What the…?” or, “I didn’t know….!”

adPreferably, by the time it hits print, broadcast or online media, it’s old news. Beyond the headline and a lead sentence, there’s little or no need for busy people in my organization to invest much time digesting the media’s take on something I’ve already fed through my internal memo.

What do you think?

Oh, and by the way, Chicago Tribune:  Zaire was the former name of the African nation known today as Democratic Republic of the Congo. The name was officially reverted in 1997.

Ouch again!

LINK:

“For more vacationers, getaways are a chance to give,” by Andrea L. Brown, Chicago Tribune, August 28, 2009 http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/chi-vacation-volunteer-nzone-28-aug28,0,6706831.story

Comments (2)

20/20 Vision for Communications

 

Mark Schumann, ABC
Mark Schumann, ABC

From blogs and podcasts to Facebook and Twitter, the medium is not the message anymore; the medium is the catalyst for conversations and relationships, according to Mark Schumann, an accredited business communicator (ABC) and principal at Towers Perrin.   Schumann discussed how professional communicators can survive in the new communication world during the August 27 professional development program hosted by the Houston chapter of the International Association of Business Communicators (IABC).

Schumann says the controlled environment, once seen as an opportunity for controlled messaging, is now an open communication marketplace where almost anyone can be heard and garner credibilty without traditional notions of editing and vetting.  New media tools, he explained, tap a hunger in people to connect, build relationships that supersede boundaries of geography or time, and create communities that reach beyond traditional limits.

See photos and videos at: http://www.flickr.com/photos/feliciagriffin and http://vimeo.com/channels/57522.

 For more information, visit http://www.iabchouston.com.

Leave a Comment

Measuring PR’s Value and Impact on Business – Part 4

In a presentation to during a recent PRSA Houston luncheon meeting, Angela Jeffrey, APR, and vice president of editorial research at VMS, highlighted her findings from nearly a decade of studies on how earned and paid media in public relations correlate to business outcomes.  

news coverageIn addition to discussing the importance of communication share over absolute values and explaining why media costs have a higher correlation to outcomes than media reach, Jeffrey also shared insights and perspectives on ROI, message consistency, and how integrating data better predicts outcomes.

ROI 21) The return on investment in advertising focuses on quantitative metrics, not the impact of creative production. An impression on TV is not the same as a print impression or an Internet impression because the dollar expenditures are different, she noted.  “So advertising needs to gocreative idea beyond spend with a qualitative metric just like non-paid news media.  Quantity and quality need to be combined for best correlations.”     

2) Message consistency needs to be managed throughout all communications. This is about accounting for the difference in effectiveness of a single ad treatment in a positive vs. negative news environment, Jeffrey said. 

Take the hypothetical example of a restaurant chain’s $30 million ad campaign that indexes at 100.  If a YouTube video exposing E.colie.coli contamination at some outlets indexes at 20, the $30 million budget now has an impact of only $6 million (20 percent of $30 million).  Jeffrey’s research found that substituting $6 million for $30 million in the company’s market mix model came close to reality in customer count and revenue estimates.  

Bottom line: ads only do well in a positive PR environment. 

ad2media coverage3) Integrating news and advertising results in greater actionable insights. By definition, a correlation is a relationship between two independent variables.  Perfect correlation, achievable only in a clinical lab, is stated as r = 1.0.  According to Jeffrey, an r = 0.7 is usually a good indication that there is a relationship between the media effort and business results.  

One of her studies revealed strong correlations between integrated communications and movie box office success.  Specifically, while paid r = 0.58 and non-paid r = 0.75, integrated r = 0.80. 

White papers:

See “Exploring the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes” and “Exploring the Link Between SHARE of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes,” by Dr. Donald Stacks, Dr. David Michaelson, and Angela Jeffrey, APR, on www.instituteforpr.com. To request a copy of “The New Found Impact of PR on Advertising,” email ajeffrey@vmsinfo.com.

Leave a Comment

Measuring PR’s value and impact on business – Part 3

The desire to do a better job is a major reason for evaluating PR efforts, but another equally important reason is the widespread adoption of the management-by-objectives system by clients and employers of PR pros.  They want to know whether the money, time, and effort expended on PR are well spent and contribute to the realization of an organizational objective,dollar sign such as attendance at an open house, product sales, or increased awareness.

media coverage1Compiling print and broadcast mentions is a widely practiced form of evaluating PR programs.  This, however, is just the first level of assessing message exposure to potential audiences. 

Media impressions are measures of the potential audience reached by a print, broadcast or online outlet.  If, for example, a story about anreadership organization appears in a local daily that has a circulation of 130,000, the media impressions are 130,000.  If another story is published the next day, this counts for 130,000 more impressions.  If there’s a brief mention of a new product or service on NBC’s Today show, this might constitute 20 million impressions if that is the audited size of the audience that regularly watches that program. 

Calculating the value of message exposure is another approach that can be done by converting stories in the regular news columns or on the air into the newspaper1advertising value equivalent, or AVE.  In other words, a five-inch article in a magazine that charges $1000 per column inch for advertising would be worth $5000 in publicity value.

“This math is correct if – and that’s a big if — the article really was about your organization.  If you only got a sentence or two, then you would be more accurate to go with a couple column inches before calculating its value,” said Angela Jeffrey, APR, vice

Angela Jeffrey, APR

Angela Jeffrey, APR

 president of editorial research at VMS who spoke at a recent PRSA Houston luncheon meeting.  

“My point on AVE is simply this: the very term ‘advertising value equivalency’ implies that a news article is equal to an ad in terms of impact.  And no one believes that. So it has been inaccurate for us as PR pros over the past 50 years to refer to a dollar amount of news coverage as having an actual ‘value.’” 

The real value of a story may be much greater than what the ad space cost to buy it, Jeffrey explains.  “It may have generated $50,000 in product sales, or solved a crisis that could have cost the company $50 million dollars.”  

In fact, some PR pros take the approach of calculating the cost of advertising adfor the same amount of space and then multiplying that total three to six times to reflect the common belief that a news story has greater credibility than an advertisement.  There is no empirical evidence, however, to support any multiplier factor.

Other pros say it’s like comparing apples to oranges. apples to oranges Advertising copy is directly controlled by the organization and can be oriented to specific objectives.  The organization also controls the size and placement of the message.  News mentions, by contrast, are determined by media gatekeepers and can be negative, neutral or positive.  Also, a new release can be edited to the point that key corporate messages are deleted; therefore, the organization can’t control size, placement, or content.

Thus, it’s a question of what’s being measured.  Should an article be counted as equivalent advertising space if it is negative?  It’s also questionable whether a 15-inch article that mentions the organization only once among six other organizations is comparable to the same amount of advertising space. 

And the numbers game doesn’t take into account that a four-inch article in the Wall Street Journal may be more valuable in reaching key publics than a 20-inch article in Houston Chronicle.

employeesSome argue that AVE metrics help corporate management put a value on PR. Others say it helps marketing executives decide on how to split resources between PR and marketing.

”From a pure calculation perspective, yes, you use the space/time occupied by your client in the story, multiplied by the advertising rate for that media outlet. However, we advise our clients not to refer to it as a ‘value’ statement,” Jeffrey said.  “And, in fact, we often take the dollar sign off it all together, and use it simply as an index score against which to compare across time, against objectives or against competitive coverage.”

Leave a Comment

Measuring PR’s Value and Impact on Business – Part 2

Angela Jeffrey, APR

Angela Jeffrey, APR

Media costs have a higher correlation to business outcomes than reach, according to Angela Jeffrey, APR, vice president of editorial research at VMS.  During a recent PRSA Houston luncheon, Jeffrey discussed her perspectives on how measurement can prove the value of PR to an organization.

By definition, a correlation is a relationship between two independent variables.  Perfect correlation, achievable only in a clinical lab, is stated as r = 1.0.  An r = 0.7 is usually a good indication that there is a relationship between the media effort and business results, according to Jeffrey.  

To see an illustrative worksheet correlating paid advertising, earned media and movie theater box office results, click here:

http://www.slideshare.net/FeliciaGriffin/correlating-outcomes

“To determine actual proof, however, we’d need to move to regression analysis, which is usually done with a much larger data set by market mix modeling firms that analyze paid-media, product distribution, pricing, weather, econometrics and other factors,” Jeffrey explained.  “Even though correlations can’t give us solid proof in PR, it is far more convincing to the C-Suite to at least generate a simple correlation in an Excel spreadsheet than to present a book of media clips.”

Jeffrey’s examination of PR for a worldwide Christian charity fundraisingfundraising effort illustrates her point.  Her research team analyzed the charity group’s media coverage for 31 days following the Myanmar disaster.  As the outcome measure, the amount of funds raised daily was tracked.  Each media story was analyzed for tone.  All of the negative stories were subtracted from the combined total of positive and neutral stories, resulting in a number of net positive scores per day.  

media coverageFORMULA:

positive stories + neutral stories – negative stories = net positive stories

 Jeffrey contrasted daily net positive clip counts, net positive audiencenewspaper online impressions, and net positive media values, and correlated them to the funds raised per day.

The results:

Media Value r = 0.73

Audience Impressions r = 0.63

Clip Counts r = 0.49 

Utilizing the increased granularity of media values improved correlations to outcomes by 32 percent over audience impressions and 70 percent over story clip counts.  

What does this mean to a PR person? 

“If you are monitoring your success by clip counts or audience impressionspublic relations and trying to correlate them to outcomes like sales, funds raised or survey scores, you may not see a high enough correlation to show that a relationship exists between the two,” Jeffrey said.  “Your analysis will look more like your media coverage did not work.  You will not see an accurate picture of your share.”  

Jeffrey says media costs work because the specific amount of space or time occupied by each company in a story can be parsed out and converted to an objective media cost number to which other qualitative metrics can be applied. “It just gives you more precision and objectivity.”

What do you think?  Any questions?  Post a comment below.

Leave a Comment

Measuring PR’s Value and Impact on Business – Part 1

measurementThanks to sophisticated software programs and techniques such as computerized news clip analysis, survey sampling, quasi-experimental designs and attempts to correlate efforts directly with sales, PR pros are making considerable progress in evaluation measurement and the ability to tell clients and employers what’s been accomplished. This coincides with the increase in the percentage of PR budgets (as much as 10 percent, according to some industry analysts) being devoted to this step because of constant pressure for PR to justify its overall budget and prove its value to organizations’ bottom lines.

Among measurements of production, message exposure, audiencemedia coverage1 awareness, audience attitudes and audience action, the most widely practiced form of PR evaluation is compilation of print and broadcast mentions.  Burrelles/Luce, for example, claims it can monitor 40 million blogs and Internet forums and tens of thousands of newspapers, magazines, trade journals, TV, and cable stations.  National Aircheck searches almost 8,000 hours of news talk radio each week.

All of this electronic research enables PR to do a fairly accurate count of how many media stories are generated by a program or campaign.  The number of media placements, however, is just the first level of assessing the exposure of the message to potential audiences.

readershipThe potential audiences reached are described as media impressions.  While commonly used in advertising to document the breadth of penetration of a particular message, media impressions don’t, however, document how many people actually read or heard the stories and, more important, how many absorbed or acted on the information.

“PR pros who tout big impressions or media value numbers as evidence of their good work without considering competitive share are not adequately advising their management or clients,” said Angela Jeffrey, APR, vice

Angela Jeffrey, APR

Angela Jeffrey, APR

president of editorial research at VMS.  During a recent PRSA Houston luncheon, Jeffrey provided an overview of her extensive work on how best to correlate non-paid media to business outcomes.

Through hundreds of studies on millions of clips over nearly a decade, Jeffrey explained how the combination of artificial intelligence and human scoring led to clarified insights that were previously impossible to see.  In recent years, she has focused on relating the results to paid media and integrating the total results to outcomes.

“Share of communication is what matters, not absolute values,” Jeffrey said.  “Your company can earn a huge amount of media coverage or buy a huge amount of advertising, but if competitors are doing a lot more, your efforts will be dwarfed and less effective.  So you have to know your share of paid or earned media to understand how your work is stacking up and create strategies to gain share.”

For example, Jeffrey pointed out, smaller competitors may not be able to afford to purchase as much but they can generate earned media if they are innovative enough.  “While it is unrealistic to expect a small player to out-shout a mammoth competitor, it is always possible to out-shout it in niche areas, special product lines, geographic areas, or whatever their particular objective,” she said.

Leave a Comment

Check out my writing samples

businessI recently had a bunch of articles, press releases and other materials that I authored and published scanned into a PDF.  My thought was that this would make it convenient to send to people as an email attachment. 

Wrong!  It’s way too big.  Nearly 8MB, to be exact.  My Yahoo! email attachment limit is apparently a miniscule 150KB.

As a solution, I’ve discovered I can upload the PDF file to SlideShare. So now, all I have to do is  just share this link:

http://www.slideshare.net/FeliciaGriffin/felicia-griffin-writing-samples

and folks can go view and download my material whenever they want. 

SlideShare is the world’s largest community for sharing presentations.slideshare

Individuals and organizations upload presentations to share their ideas, connect with others, and generate leads for their businesses. Anyone can find presentations on topics that interest them. You can also tag, download, or embed presentations into your own blogs and websites.

SlideShare gets your slides out there on the web, so your ideas can be found and shared by a wide audience. Do you want to get the word out about your product or service? Reach people who could not make it to your talk? Are you a teacher looking to share your lesson plans?

Some of the things you can do on SlideShare:

  • Embed slideshows into your own blog or website.
  • Share slideshows publicly or privately. There are several ways to share privately.
  • Synch audio to your slides.
  • Market your own event on slideshare.
  • Join groups to connect with SlideShare members who share your interests.
  • Download the original file.

What do you think about that?  Leave a comment below!

Leave a Comment

From Homeless to Harvard

Khadijah's hope triumphs over her adversity.

Khadijah's hope triumphs over her adversity.

An inspiring story.  Thanks to my friend Arlene Jennings for sharing.

 

http://www.jackandjillpolitics.com/2009/06/from-homeless-to-harvard/

Leave a Comment

Social media and higher education

Leave a Comment

K.I.S.S.: Social Media Communication Tips

What do you think about this?

  1. Listen before you talk.
  2. Say who you are.
  3. Show your personality.
  4. Ignore your English teacher.
  5. Respond to ideas, not people.
  6. Remember — it’s a conversation.
Freeman: social media engages global stakeholders.
Freeman: social media engages global stakeholders.

Tips from Julie Freeman, ABC, APR, who is president of the International Association of Business Communicators.  She delivered the keynote presentation during the Houston IABC luncheon on July 23.

Since becoming president of IABC in 2001, Freeman has worked to improve the association’s financial health and enhance the value of IABC membership.  Major projects have included a branding initiative and introduction of web-based and social-networking tools. 

Her blog, Julie’s Corner, http://juliefreeman.x.iabc.com/ can be found on the IABC Café on the IABC web site. She also participates in a monthly podcast, Café2Go, http://blogs.iabc.com/cafe2go/2009/05/20/cafe2go-podcast-32-may-2009/ with the IABC Chair.

Photos and video: http://www.flickr.com/photos/feliciagriffin/

Comments (7)

Older Posts »